Shingle vs Metal: Repair Guide

When it comes to repairs, asphalt shingles are significantly more affordable—typically 30-50% cheaper than metal roof repairs. Here's the breakdown. For more detailed pricing, check our complete cost guide.

Asphalt Shingle Repair Costs

• Minor repairs (few shingles): $200-$500
• Moderate repairs (leak, flashing): $400-$1,000
• Major repairs: $800-$2,000

Metal Roof Repair Costs

• Minor repairs (seam, small rust): $400-$800
• Moderate repairs (panel replacement): $600-$1,500
• Major repairs: $1,200-$3,500

Metal costs more because it requires specialized knowledge, tools, and materials. Not all roofing contractors work with metal—you need someone experienced with standing seam panels, exposed fastener systems, and proper sealing techniques. However, metal roofs need repairs far less frequently, which offsets higher individual repair costs over the roof's lifetime. Dealing with leaks? The approach differs significantly between materials.

Asphalt Shingles: Easy & Common

Shingle repairs are straightforward. Any reputable roofing contractor can replace damaged shingles, repair flashing, or patch leaks. Materials are available at any roofing supply store. Most repairs can be done in a few hours. The simplicity and widespread contractor expertise keep costs down.

Metal Roofing: Specialized Skills Required

Metal roof repairs require specific expertise. Seam repairs need understanding of thermal expansion and contraction. Panel replacement must match the original metal type to avoid galvanic corrosion. Exposed fastener systems need proper fastener replacement to maintain weather-tightness. Finding qualified metal roofers can be challenging in some areas, and scheduling may take longer. Need emergency service? Fewer metal specialists means longer wait times.

Here's where metal roofs shine: they rarely need repairs. A properly installed metal roof can go 15-20 years without any repair needs, while asphalt shingles typically need attention every 5-10 years.

Asphalt Shingles: Regular Maintenance

Shingles are more susceptible to wind damage, UV degradation, and weather wear. Expect to replace some shingles after major storms. Flashing and valley repairs are common as shingles age. By year 15, repairs become frequent enough that replacement often makes more sense than ongoing patches.

Metal: Few But Costlier Repairs

Metal roofs resist weather damage better. When they do need repairs, it's usually seam leaks, rust spots, or fastener issues. Once repaired properly, those areas typically stay fixed. The trade-off is clear: higher repair costs but far fewer repairs needed overall. Check if your insurance policy covers metal roof repairs—some have restrictions.